Add Your Review
Thanks for visiting Magee Diner. We'd love to have your feedback!
Our Latest Reviews
Chicken Parmesan
Meal was a very generous portion and absolutely delicious! The chicken was moist and cooked perfectly and there was a wonderful crispness to the coating! Would highly recommend eating here! We were very happy with the service considering we had a large group everything went well! We will definitely eat here again!
Patty Melt
We love Magee Diner! We live in the Buffalo area but frequently travel the NYS Thruway to visit family and friends and we try to plan every trip across central New York to include a stop at Magee Diner. The patty melt is my absolute favorite, but we have tried many menu items over the years and have yet to be disappointed. All the food is of high quality, the prices are reasonable, and the service is always friendly! Top notch COVID-19 precautions in place as well. Highly highly recommend to anyone looking for a great place to eat!
Prime Rib Dinner Special - Served Every Saturday
Best when finished with strawberry shortcake for dessert!!
Prime Rib Dinner Special - Served Every Saturday
Ribs were very uniquely flavored. Good to the taste buds. Fries are always on point. I love eating here. Its a little sweet spot in the heart of the Waterloo area.
Two Eggs Over Corned Beef Hash & Toast
This meal is perfect I left full and happy for sure!! What a great meal
New and Improved Mac and Cheese
I am a bit of a macaroni and cheese "snob", and usually only like my own. This is, hands down, the very best macaroni and cheese I have EVER eaten!
Country Sausage Omelette
I was passing through from indiana and we stopped for breakfast at Magee's. What a pleasant experience and the food was exceptional!!! We will stop back in on our next trip to the east coast.
Country Sausage Omelette
To me this really is the best breakfast thing to live for.
Roast Beef
Always great food and service.
Fish Fry
Their Friday Fresh Fish Fry Dinner is literally THE BEST I have ever had! Keep up the good work guys! Ps...service is always amazing as well!
Fish Fry
My dinner was excellent, the fish and chips were both cooked to a golden brown and crispy. We stop here for lunch or dinner whenever we shop at the outlets and have never been disappointed. The food and the service is excellent!!!!!
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Delicious wrap! Everyone's food at the table was great. We had a mix of lunch and breakfast items and appetizers. Friendly wait staff. You won't be dissapointed !
We follow all NYS guildlines and CDC recommendation
This place is awesome and affordable. Employees are sincerely nice. There is limited truck parking there but, the Petro is behind it with tons of parking. I have eaten soooooooo many menu items and have been pleased with all of them.
Bacon Cheddar Burger
I have had this burger many times. The food and service at Magee diner is consistently fantastic!
Homemade Meatloaf
Bring my father in with walker lots of room to maneuver around staff is always friendly to and old guy and asked me where he was if he wasn't with me. Keep up the good work.
Chicken-Fried Steak
My husband and I love your chicken-fried steak dinner!!!! We are there every week and every Sunday morning for breakfast. We love it when you have this as a breakfast special too!! And your waitresses are amazing!! Thank you. Bill and Colleen Rogers 315-879-8379
Chicken Tenders & Fries
Magees Diner has the best chicken tenders and fries!! So far, out of every restraunt or diner I have visited nothing can beat Magees chicken tenders and fries.
Burger & Fries
Burger was best I've had in a LONG time. Big, juicy, great toppings (THANK YOU for still using iceberg lettuce!) And fries were cooked perfectly, HOT, and crispy. The parking lot was moderately full and expected a wait, but they had an open table and counter space free. No delay on service, food arrived in reasonable time and checking out was timely. Same as my previous visits!!
Sausage Benedict
Stopped on a whim, driven by this diner many times and noticed the parking lot was always busy when the lights were on. A surprise to find a meal like this on a menu. Great taste and very ample portion. I was with 3 others and we all ate well. If you walk away hungry you are on your own!!!!
Grilled Ham & Cheese
This is a go-to stop on our trips to Western NY several times a year. We have had both breakfasts and lunches there and never been disappointed; fairly priced and superbly crafted meals on all accounts. I generally stick with the sandwiches which are all made with meats prepared in-house. Thick deli slabs no matter what you order. The service is warm and welcoming AND prompt ! We highly recommend. Easily accessed from the NYS Thruway exit 41.
Fish Fry
Excellent food! Great service! The waitress answered our inquiries and helped us make the best choice. Dessert was amazing. Definitely returning.
Reuben
I've tried Reubens everywhere and this is one of the best! I've been going to Magee Diner for years and have yet to be disappointed.
Roast Turkey
Great sandwich, lots of turkey had mashed potatoes and gravy with the meal. Was ready when I pulled in to pick my order up.
Philly Steak Sandwich & Fries
The sandwich was very good well done just how i like it. Fries were well seasoned. I'd come here any time of the day.
BBQ Pulled Pork
The pulled pork was so tender. I know a few restaurants that specialize in BBQ in Syracuse NY but Maher's is the best. Love their baked beans too.
Eggs Benedict
Perfect stop on way to/from our annual Family vacation! Great food, friendly staff and good parking for our boat! Breakfast is awesome especially the "specials".
Steak & Eggs
The steak and eggs breakfast is great! The steak is very tender and cooked as requested. We go for our girls weekend and my friend ordered the hungry man breakfast and couldn't finish it there was so much! We have had quite a few items on the menu and never had a bad meal. All was very tasty and delicious! We are going again in July and definitely stopping!
Country Sausage Omelette
Nice, friendly servers. Loved this omlet.
Corned Beef Hash & Cheese Omelette
I'm a big corned beef hash lover , so when I saw this I had to try . Now I get it most times I visit . I've tried to make it at home , but doesn't stack up !! Can't wait for this pandemic to end so we can once again dine here .
Carrot Cake
I have gone 20+ years without that homeade, yummy tasting, carrot cake. Until...I had a slice of carrot cake at the Diner!! That first bite, put me at my grandmother's house in the late 90's. Her icebox carrot cake was the most amazing thing I have ever had. Magee Diner's carrot cake is simply...amazing! I will be able to reminisce each and every time I go there. Thank you.
Julienne Salad
This salad is huge! Very fresh and tasty! Will definitely get it again 😊
Country Sausage Omelette
OMG !! If you have never eaten at the Magee Diner, you have to stop in and try the Country Sausage Omelette it is amazing !!!
Prime Rib Dinner Special - Served Every Saturday
Not only is this the cutest diner, the food is definitely worth every bite ! Prime rib is a must ;)
Open 9a to 2pm
Our favorite place to eat in Waterloo!!! Best country fried steak ever!!! We eat at the Msgee Diner every week.
L.A. Cinnamon French Toast
Hello, just wanted to say we have always had great meals at the Magee Diner!! We eat they every week and and it doesn't matter if it's breakfast, lunch, or dinner, the food is always hot and delicious!!! The wait staff are quick, attentive, and always friendly. We absolutely love the Magee Diner!! Thank you!!! Bill Rogers
The Magee "Big Burger" and Fries
turkey club also. WONDERFUL! HUGE! DELICIOUS! LARGE PORTIONS. HOT FOOD AT ITS BEST! LADIES THAT SERVE ARE THE BEST! YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED! GREAT PRICES FOR AWESOME!
Veggie Omelette With Cheese
Food was amazing! All served fresh n hot!!! Waitress was on it and doing her job well. Clean a comfortable place to eat and socialize!
Western Omelette
Really enjoyed the ham in the omelette. It wasn't dry or overly salty and it was good size for the price.
Battered Fish & Chips
my family where heading to the casino.getting off the thruway i did see a dinner,being a friday we all wanted a fish fry.it was i great Decision !!! the fish was tender and on the bigger size...it was delicious!!! keep up the great job..
Roast Beef
We have eaten at Magees many times & we absolutely LOVE everything on the menu! There are so many choices, it's always hard to make a decision, but we know regardless what we order, the taste is always phenomenal & the portions are huge! We love the "cow" decor & the whole atmosphere. Everything tastes "homemade" & the service is great! Everyone is fast & friendly all the time. If you're looking for home cooking, variety & a great price with great service this little diner is a gem!
PAST DRAWING WINNERS
September 2020:
Carol, Stroud's BBQ
Daytona Beach Shores, FL
August 2020:
Jo-El, Mick's All American
Mount Joy, PAÂ
July 2020:
Bronson, Los Dos PotrillosÂ
Colorado
June 2020:
Elish, Crump's Landing
Homosassa, FL
May 2020:
Carlson, Papi Grande's Mexican
Amherst, NY
April 2020:
Sommer, Little Calf CreameryÂ
Thousand Oaks, CA
March 2020:
Theresa, Woody's Crab House
North East, MD
February 2020:
Maria, The Rustik Fork
Riverside, CA
January 2020:
Marsha, Stefano's Restaurant
Florence, SC
December 2019:
Alma, Karai Ramen Bistro
Jacksonville, FL
November 2019:
Courtney, Axe &Â Arrow
Seattle, WA
October 2019:
Andy, Backwoods Brewing Co.
Portland, OR
September 2019:
Amanda, Home Restaurant
Los Angeles, CA
August 2019:
Jennifer, Mark's City Grill
Columbus, GA
July 2019:
Rebecca, Frank Gourmet
Buffalo, NY
June 2019:
Donna, Dino's Sports Bar
Cape Cod, MA
May 2019:
Karen, This Little Pig
Amherst, NY
April 2019:
Alicia, Plant Based Pizzeria
Atlanta, GA