Add Your Review
Thanks for visiting Magee Diner. We'd love to have your feedback!
Our Latest Reviews
This place is awesome and affordable. Employees are sincerely nice. There is limited truck parking there but, the Petro is behind it with tons of parking. I have eaten soooooooo many menu items and have been pleased with all of them.
I have had this burger many times. The food and service at Magee diner is consistently fantastic!
Hello, just wanted to say we have always had great meals at the Magee Diner!! We eat they every week and and it doesn't matter if it's breakfast, lunch, or dinner, the food is always hot and delicious!!! The wait staff are quick, attentive, and always friendly. We absolutely love the Magee Diner!! Thank you!!! Bill Rogers
turkey club also. WONDERFUL! HUGE! DELICIOUS! LARGE PORTIONS. HOT FOOD AT ITS BEST! LADIES THAT SERVE ARE THE BEST! YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED! GREAT PRICES FOR AWESOME!
Food was amazing! All served fresh n hot!!! Waitress was on it and doing her job well. Clean a comfortable place to eat and socialize!
Really enjoyed the ham in the omelette. It wasn't dry or overly salty and it was good size for the price.
my family where heading to the casino.getting off the thruway i did see a dinner,being a friday we all wanted a fish fry.it was i great Decision !!! the fish was tender and on the bigger size...it was delicious!!! keep up the great job..
We have eaten at Magees many times & we absolutely LOVE everything on the menu! There are so many choices, it's always hard to make a decision, but we know regardless what we order, the taste is always phenomenal & the portions are huge! We love the "cow" decor & the whole atmosphere. Everything tastes "homemade" & the service is great! Everyone is fast & friendly all the time. If you're looking for home cooking, variety & a great price with great service this little diner is a gem!
These are awesome!!!
This restaurant has so much going for it. The menu is so extensive. There is literally something for everyone. I had a hard time picking. I decided to give the Eggs Benedict a try as it is my favorite. I am very reluctant to order this places because hollandaise sauce is tricky. If you love this dish you know what I mean.Based on my past experiences here ,at this consistently good restaurant ,I gave it a try. Boy it certainly was wonderful. At this quaint restaurant the waitresses are so accommodating. It is very clean and it is A cozy , relaxed environment. You can have that extra coffe and you are not pressured to leave. When we go that way it is part of the fun of the day. You owe it to yourself to try Magees. Thanks. Patty
I have Celiac Disease, and rarely eat out. However, we were later than normal one night at Sauders and we had to eat. The Ranchero is normally a sandwich, but they made it without a bun for me. I was very nervous about cross contamination, especially being at a diner, but i didn't get sick at all. The meal was amazing! The chicken was well cooked, and the ample amount of bacon was well cooked. I loved every bite, and I really loved finding some place I could eat out. I don't live locally, but we travel to Sauders every couple of months. Magees may become our spot to eat. Thank you for taking the time to prepare my meal safely.
Awesome omelet with plenty of ham.
The big burger is huge! I have to squeeze it to get it into my mouth. The combination of the toppings make it the BEST burger I have ever had.
Best place for a good ole hot turkey sandwich
Beautiful home feeling diner. Ive heard great things and came in this morning. Friendy staff great food with great prices. Highly recommendable! Will be back in the future
The quesadilla was so cheesy, gooey, and just overall delicious. It was also huge, you definitely get what you paid for. The meal comes with some great pico de Gallo and sour cream as well, and would totally recommend it if you love quesadillas.
Food and service was great
If I could eat here every day I would!!! I have loved everything I have ever tried...but my favorite, so far, is the Cheeseburger Club sandwich. I am actually heading to the Diner for dinner tonight...might have to try something new!!!
Not only is this the cutest diner, the food is definitely worth every bite ! Prime rib is a must ;)
Our favorite place to eat in Waterloo!!! Best country fried steak ever!!! We eat at the Msgee Diner every week.
My husband and I love your chicken-fried steak dinner!!!! We are there every week and every Sunday morning for breakfast. We love it when you have this as a breakfast special too!! And your waitresses are amazing!! Thank you. Bill and Colleen Rogers 315-879-8379
Magees Diner has the best chicken tenders and fries!! So far, out of every restraunt or diner I have visited nothing can beat Magees chicken tenders and fries.
Burger was best I've had in a LONG time. Big, juicy, great toppings (THANK YOU for still using iceberg lettuce!) And fries were cooked perfectly, HOT, and crispy. The parking lot was moderately full and expected a wait, but they had an open table and counter space free. No delay on service, food arrived in reasonable time and checking out was timely. Same as my previous visits!!
Stopped on a whim, driven by this diner many times and noticed the parking lot was always busy when the lights were on. A surprise to find a meal like this on a menu. Great taste and very ample portion. I was with 3 others and we all ate well. If you walk away hungry you are on your own!!!!
This is a go-to stop on our trips to Western NY several times a year. We have had both breakfasts and lunches there and never been disappointed; fairly priced and superbly crafted meals on all accounts. I generally stick with the sandwiches which are all made with meats prepared in-house. Thick deli slabs no matter what you order. The service is warm and welcoming AND prompt ! We highly recommend. Easily accessed from the NYS Thruway exit 41.
The best that I have had in a restaurant
Great food! You will be impressed! I ordered the Mac and cheese with bacon, it was delicious. It was perfectly cooked, very cheesy and wasn't greasy from the bacon. Highly recommend eating here, bring the family!
Had an excellent fish fry tonight. We always enjoy our meals here. We have never had a bad meal. Tonight I had the mini fish fry, my husband had the chicken fried steak, and colleague had the bacon cheddar burger with onion rings. The waitress was very friendly. She checked on us periodically and refilled drinks. Even with the very busy evening I felt she managed it all very well. I always recommended this place. Thank you for your great food, service, and staff. This place is a staple in the area.
Best food we had in a long time, extremely friendly staff, stop by grab a bite, you won't regret it
The "Big Burger" is the BEST burger that I have ever tasted! The special combination of toppings makes my senses go wild. Very generous amount of french fries is included. Not greasy.
Very Delicious! Every time I visit, they are consistent, friendly, and yummy!
Perfect patty melt on rye!
We were the first in the door upon opening during the farm show. The food was good, we enjoyed our time there! It got really busy shortly after we arrived. The best part is I accidentally left my business card. However they safeguarded it once they found it. They were very helpful regarding it. I live several hrs away, they happily secured my card and carefully sent it back to me. Very pleased and thankful.
Love the food here! Always fresh, big portions, and the wait staff is friendly always!
The best!!..we love stopping there when we can!!..
PAST DRAWING WINNERS
Courtney, Axe & Arrow
Andy, Backwoods Brewing Co., Portland, OR
Amanda, Home Restaurant, Los Angeles, CA
Jennifer, Mark's City Grill - Columbus, GA
Rebecca, Frank Gourmet - Buffalo, NY
Donna, Dino's Sports Bar - Cape Cod, MA
Karen, This Little Pig - Amherst, NY
Alicia, Plant Based Pizzeria - Atlanta, GA